Professional Indemnity and Governor's Liability Explained for Academies
What a Breach of Professional Duties Actually Means
In an academy trust, governors and trustees owe duties that come from company law, charity law, the funding agreement and the academy trust's articles of association. A breach of professional duties is not limited to deliberate wrongdoing. It can also mean a failure to act with the care, skill and diligence that a reasonable person in the same position would show.

Typical examples include approving spending without proper scrutiny, ignoring conflicts of interest, or failing to follow the trust's financial regulations. Even a single decision made without the right information can be treated as an actual or alleged breach, especially if it causes a financial loss or reputational damage.
The duty is to act honestly, reasonably and in the best interests of the academy trust at all times.
Why the Words Actual and Alleged Matter
An actual breach is one that has been established, for example through an internal investigation, an audit finding or a court judgment. An alleged breach is simply a claim that has been made but not yet proven. Both can trigger a notification to the Department for Education and can lead to a claim being brought against the trust or an individual governor.
Understanding the difference helps governors respond proportionately. An allegation may never become a formal finding, but it still requires a careful, documented response. Ignoring it often makes the situation worse.
How to Start a Governors Claim
Starting a claim usually begins with an internal review. The trust should record what happened, who was involved and what loss or harm is said to have occurred. Minutes, finance reports and correspondence are the evidence that will shape the claim.
- Gather the relevant governing body papers and minutes.
- Identify the specific duty that is said to have been breached.
- Notify the trust's insurers and legal advisers promptly.
- Complete the appropriate claim form with clear, factual information.
Governors should not admit liability or discuss the matter publicly before advice is taken. A single misplaced email can become part of the case.
Key Duties and Common Risk Areas
The table below sets out some common duties and the risks that flow from them.
| Duty | Example of Breach | Likely Claim |
|---|---|---|
| Financial oversight | Approving a budget without evidence | Recovery of losses |
| Conflicts of interest | Failing to declare a personal interest | Breach of trust |
| Health and safety | Ignoring a known risk on site | Personal injury |
| Employment duties | Unfair or unlawful dismissal | Employment tribunal |
Protecting Governors and Trustees
Professional indemnity cover and governor's liability cover exist precisely for these situations. They can pay defence costs and compensation, and they usually require early notification. Checking the policy wording before an incident occurs is a simple but effective risk control.
- Read the policy and note the notification deadline.
- Keep decision records accurate and complete.
- Take independent advice when a claim is threatened.
By treating every actual or alleged breach seriously and following the correct claim process, academy governors can protect both the trust and themselves.
